Combination sleepers need a mattress that will adjust to every sleeping position. A mattress that supports the spine comfortably and keeps it in neutral alignment during the night is vital for a healthier, more restful sleep. We’ve put together a comprehensive guide of our favorite mattresses for combination sleepers. We also go over what to look for in the right mattress and the pros and cons of each sleep position.
The Amerisleep AS3 contains plant-based Bio-Pur® foam and a special transition layer with HIVE® technology— a 5-zoned support system that adjusts to each sleep position with just the right amount of cushioning. It comes as no surprise that it’s one of our favorites for combination sleeping.
Tuft & Needle Mint™
The Tuft & Needle Mint™ mattress adds a layer of their own gel-infused transitional foam. More responsive than traditional memory foam, this transitional layer makes it easier to switch and adjust to each sleep position.
8 Best Mattresses for Combination Sleepers
|Amerisleep AS3||Contains HIVE® technology to promote healthy sleep in any position.|| |
|Tuft & Needle Mint™||Contains 30% more cooling gels than the original to keep you sleeping comfortably.|| |
|Original Purple®||Features Purple's® proprietary Smart Comfort Grid™ to alleviate pressure points.|| |
|Luxi 3-in-1||Comes with customizable layers allowing you to modify your bed to meet your needs.|| |
|Bear Hybrid||Combines cooling memory foam and bouncy coils to offer you the best of both worlds.|| |
|Nest Alexander Signature||Flippable firmness gives you a 2-in-1 mattress|| |
|Nolah Original 10"||Contains proprietary AirFoam™ for enhanced pressure relief.|| |
The Amerisleep AS3 tops our list as the best mattress for combination sleepers. Not only for combination sleepers, but the Amerisleep AS3 is also one of the best mattresses you can buy due to its adaptability.
Standing at 12 inches tall, it contains 3 inches of Bio-Pur® memory foam, a 2-inch layer of transition foam with HIVE® technology, and 7 inches of Bio-Core® foam. The cover features a soft, breathable cover that keeps air moving through the mattress and is also easily washable
Each layer is available exclusively through Amerisleep. The Bio-Pur® layer is plant-based and open-cell, preventing sagging while conforming to the body. The Affinity layer with HIVE® technology is a special, 5-zone transition layer— it reacts to each body position to evenly support weight and relieve pressure points. The high-density Bio-Core® layer is made using eco-friendly processes and provides a sturdy foundation for the other layers to rest on.
Amerisleep AS3 Warranty and Sleep Trial
Amerisleep’s 20-year warranty is one of the best in the market. They cover defects not caused by misuse, including sagging greater than 0.75 inches and faulty manufacturer defects. During the first 10 years, Amerisleep will repair or replace the mattress at no extra cost to the customer. Starting in the 11th year, Amerisleep will replace the mattress at a prorated charge of 50% of the original cost.
100-Night Sleep Trial
Amerisleep’s 100-night sleep trial allows customers to try out their mattress in the comfort of their own home. While not required, Amerisleep highly recommends keeping the mattress for at least 30 days for the body to break in the mattress and adjust to the new sleep surface. If the customer is not satisfied, Amerisleep will arrange for a pick-up and donate the mattress to a local charity before issuing a full refund.
2. Tuft & Needle Mint
The Tuft & Needle Mint mattress stands at 12 inches thick and includes 3 inches of graphite-infused Adaptive® Foam, 2 inches of gel-infused transitional poly-foam, and a 7-inch layer of poly-foam. It comes encased in a soft, plush polyester blend cover.
With the additional poly-foam transitional layer, Tuft & Needle created a mattress with better cooling and body-contouring capabilities. The exclusive Adaptive® Foam is more responsive than traditional memory foam making it easier for combo sleepers to switch positions at night. Plus, its excellent motion isolation reduces sleep disruptions from the movements of a sleep partner.
Tuft & Needle Mint Warranty and Sleep Trial
Tuft & Needle’s warranty covers sagging greater than 0.75 inch, manufacturing defects, and anything that could cause the foam to split or crack not caused through misuse. The mattress cover is also included in the warranty, covering loose stitching, a broken zipper, and tears in the fabric not caused by improper use.
100-Night Sleep Trial
Tuft & Needle offers customers a hassle-free, 100-night sleep trial. Customers can return their mattress within the sleep trial if unsatisfied for any reason. While Tuft & Needle will issue a full refund, if the mattress was shipped to Alaska or Hawaii, they will not refund the shipping fees.
3. Original Purple®
The Original Purple® mattress stands at 9.5 inches tall and includes 2 inches of Hyper-Elastic Polymer™, 3.5 inches of polyurethane foam, and 4 inches of high-density foam. The mattress cover is made from a blend of polyester, viscose, and Lycra.
Purple’s® exclusive Hyper-Elastic Polymer™ layer is a stretchy, gel-like material built to conform to the natural curves of the body, relieving pressure points and helping the spine stay neutrally aligned. The material is highly adaptive, keeping its shape no matter the weight and stays temperature neutral, so sleepers won’t overheat.
Purple® Warranty and Sleep Trial
Purple® covers sagging greater than 1 inch, and in the case of an authorized defect, they can choose whether to send out a replacement or have the mattress repaired. Repairs and replacements are free of charge, however, customers must cover transportation and inspection fees. The mattress cover is under warranty for 2 years.
100-Night Sleep Trial
For 100 nights, if customers don’t absolutely love the Original Purple® mattress, Purple® will gladly pick it up for a full refund. Customers must cover shipping fees.
4. Luxi 3-in-1
The Luxi 3-in-1 mattress is 11 inches tall and includes a 1 inch layer of memory foam attached to 3.5 inches of support balancing foam pillars, followed by 1.5 inches of synthetic latex foam, 1.5 inches of transitional poly-foam, and 3.5 inches of base poly-foam. The cover is made of quilted rayon.
What makes the Luxi 3-in-1 mattress stand out is its customizable layers. Customers can easily zip off the cover to change up the layers for a tailored sleep experience. Luxi even provides a 1000-night pledge— sleep experts will consult customers about their sleep experience, then work with them to add or subtract layers to achieve the perfect fit. Split customization is offered for queen sizes and larger, an ideal option for couples.
The Shape Match Technology of the Luxi 3-in-1 mattress involves a grid system of a foam pillars designed to collapse under areas of concentrated weight and fit around the body’s natural curves. Altogether, this mattress easily adjusts to different sleep positions, contouring to the body and relieving pressure for a better night’s sleep.
Luxi Warranty and Sleep Trial
Luxi covers sagging greater than 1.5 inches, physical flaws that may cause the foam to split or crack not caused by improper use. Luxi will also send replacements of defective pieces. The customer is responsible for all shipping and transportation costs. If a customer chooses to upgrade their mattress, a new warranty will be issued on the date of purchase.
100-Night Sleep Trial
Luxi requires customers to keep the mattress for at least a period of 30 days to allow the body to properly adjust to the new mattress. If not satisfied after 30 days, Luxi offers a free consultation to help adjust the mattress to the customer’s preferred comfort level. If customers are still not happy, Luxi will schedule to have the mattress picked up and donated before issuing a full refund.
5. Bear Hybrid
The Bear Hybrid mattress is 14 inches thick with 2 inches of gel memory foam, 2 inches of Serene® foam, 1 inch of transitional foam, 8 inches of pocketed coils, and 1 inch of high-density support foam. Their mattress cover incorporates FDA-determined Celliant® technology.
Bear’s special Serene® foam provides 4 times more pressure relief than other leading memory foam brands. It adapts to any body type and sleep position for consistent pressure relief and comfort. The conforming layers of foam combined with the structured support of pocket coils gives a plush yet responsive sleep surface.
Bear Hybrid Warranty and Sleep Trial
For the first 10 years, Bear will repair or replace the mattress free of charge, with the exception of handling or transportation costs. Starting on the 11th year, Bear may choose to either repair the bed or replace it at a prorated charge plus transportation costs. The prorated charge starts at 50% of the original purchase price, and increases by 5% each year. Defects covered included indentations greater than 1.5 inches and physical flaws causing the foam to crack or split.
100-Night Sleep Trial
Bear requires its customers to keep the mattress for 30 days to allow the body to adjust to the new bed. After 30 days, if customers are not satisfied, Bear will pick up the mattress to donate to a local charity before issuing a full refund.
6. Nest Alexander Signature
The Nest Alexander Signature mattress is 14 inches tall and includes 1.5 inches of CoolFlow™ quilted foam, 2 inches of gel memory foam, 2 inches of transitional poly-foam, a 7-inch poly-foam base, and 1.5 inches of CoolFlow™ quilted foam. The cover is made from organic cotton.
The flippable structure of this mattress makes it a versatile option for those whose sleep surface preferences change. One side is medium and the other is luxury firm. The contouring comfort of the top foam layers offer excellent support. The poly-foam base prevents sagging and improves edge support.
Nest Alexander Signature Warranty and Sleep Trial
Nest’s lifetime warranty lasts as long as the original purchaser owns it and lasts for the lifetime of the mattress. In case of a defect, Nest will repair or replace the mattress at no extra cost to the customer. Defects include indentations greater than 1 inch, manufacturing flaws in the cover zipper, and physical flaws in the cover not caused through misuse.
100-Night Sleep Trial
Nest offers customers a 100-night sleep trial— if they don’t love it, they can arrange to have the mattress picked up and donated to a local charity for a full refund. Nest does require a mandatory 30-day break-in period before they’ll process any returns.
7. Nolah Original 10″
The Nolah Original 10″ mattress is, as the name implies, 10 inches tall. It includes 2 inches of AirFoam™, 1 inch of support foam, and 7 inches of high-density base foam. The mattress cover is made from soft viscose, a breathable, moisture-wicking material.
Nolah’s AirFoam™ is softer and more breathable than traditional memory foam. It supports the hips when sleeping on your back, and also relieves pressure in the shoulders and hips while side sleeping. It may be too soft for stomach sleepers, but the Nolah Original 10 mattress is a great choice for sleepers who switch between their backs and sides. Sleepers will feel like they’re sleeping on, not in the mattress.
Nolah Original 10 Warranty and Sleep Trial
During the warranty period, Nolah will repair or replace the mattress free of charge, including shipping costs. Covered defects, not caused by improper use, include: sagging greater than 1 inch, damage to foam from manufacturer, unraveling seams, and flaws in the cover zipper.
120-Night Sleep Trial
Nolah’s 120-night sleep trial requires customers to keep the mattress for 30 days to properly adjust to the bed. If after those 30 days, the customer is still not happy with the mattress, Nolah will pick it up free of charge for a full refund.
Factors to Consider When Buying a Combination Mattress
Combination sleepers need a balance of consistent comfort and support— this is key to keeping the spine aligned.
When looking for the best mattress for combination sleepers, potential customers need to be aware of the mattress material, level of firmness and support, responsiveness of the sleep surface, whether the mattress has good motion isolation, body weight, price tag, and if a sleep trial, warranty, and return policy are offered.
The four basic sleeping positions have both pros and cons. Combination sleepers can reap the benefits from each sleep position, but also face the drawbacks of each.
The side sleeping position is one of the most popular and the healthiest sleeping positions. Side sleeping enables better oxygen intake and reduces the risk of snoring. Sleeping on the side, particularly the right side removes pressure from vital organs like the lungs and liver, and helps reduce acid reflux.
- Decreased risk of snoring
- Lying on the left side removes pressure from vital organs
- Increased risk of developing facial wrinkles
- Numbness/pain in shoulders and arms
Back sleeping aligns the spine. While it does open airways, there is a risk of snoring and developing sleep apnea—sleeping on the back may cause the collapse of soft tissue at the back of the throat, blocking the air passage.
- Neutral sleep position ideal for healthy spine alignment
- Reduced risk of twisting the body
- Increased risk of snoring
- Can worsen sleep apnea symptoms
Stomach sleeping is the least recommended sleep position because of the many health risks associated with it, like neck strain and lower back pain. Neck strain is caused when stomach sleepers twist their neck to the side at an unnatural angle to breath. Lying on the stomach causes gravity to straighten the natural curve of the spine, causing lower back pain.
- Reduced risk of snoring
- Possible stiffness in neck from twisting it at unnatural angles
- Possible lower back pain from gravity pulling against the spine’s natural curve
The type of material found in a mattress may impact how much sleep a combination sleeper can achieve. For example, if a combination sleeper chooses a firm innerspring mattress, they may encounter more pressure points and less conforming, resulting in possible sleep disruptions and waking with aches and pains the following morning. Firmness level can range depending on the material. Since combination sleepers do best on a medium-firm mattress, memory foam, latex, innersprings, and hybrids would be the best mattress types for them.
Memory foam mattresses contain at least two layers— a high-density poly-foam base and a memory foam comfort layer. With good motion isolation, memory foam offers consistent support while contouring to the body. Combination sleepers should avoid memory foam mattresses with a deep sinking sensation, since it makes it harder to change positions. Combination sleepers need a memory foam mattress where they sleep on instead of in the mattress.
Natural latex is derived from the sap of rubber trees, while synthetic latex is made through a chemical process. There are two types of natural latex— Dunlop and Talalay. Dunlop latex is denser in structure, but more durable. Talalay latex contains strategically placed ventilation holes that offer targeted support with a softer feel.
A latex mattress may contain both a comfort latex layer and a support latex layer. Latex, like memory foam, conforms to the body to relieve pressure, however, latex is more responsive and tends to sleep cooler. This type of mattress comes at a higher cost, especially if it contains natural latex.
An innerspring mattress consists of steel coils with a comfort layer on top. The contouring ability of an innerspring depends on the material and thickness of the comfort layer. Innerspring mattresses provide consistent support and are highly responsive. They usually have better edge support and sleep cooler compared to other mattress types.
A hybrid mattress contains a combination of coils and foam— pocket coils act as a support layer with some type of foam as a comfort layer. For a mattress to be a true hybrid, it should have at least 3 inches of foam in it as well as a coil layer. Pocket coils give excellent support while reducing motion transfer and noise.
Hybrid mattresses have good edge support, so sleepers won’t feel like they’re about to roll off the bed. They also sleep cool because of the good air circulation inside the innerspring coil layer while the comfort layers contour closely to the body. Hybrid mattresses are more expensive because of the large amounts of materials they contain.
Firmness and Support
Combination sleepers will need a medium-firm mattress for optimal comfort and support. The medium-firm feel allows slight sinkage of the hips in back sleepers, good support for stomach sleepers, and the right amount of pressure-relieving comfort for side sleepers. Medium-firm helps keep the spine in constant spinal alignment despite changes in sleep position.
While it’s important for a mattress to conform to the body to relieve pressure, it’s just as important to have a responsive sleep surface. Responsiveness allows a combination sleeper to easily change sleep positions without feeling stuck.
Since combination sleepers often switch positions, a mattress with excellent motion isolation is key. Motion isolation allows the mattress to absorb a sleeper’s movement and prevent it from traveling to anyone else in the bed. A mattress with good motion isolation is especially ideal for couples. Sleep is less likely to be disrupted for both parties if a mattress absorbs any movement.
Body weight can determine the type of mattress you choose. Bodyweight affects how much you sink in a mattress and its level of support. For example, firm mattresses are a poor choice for lightweight sleepers because they don’t weigh enough to properly sink into the bed, thus losing the benefits of pressure relief and comfort. Heavyweights, however, would do better with a firm bed because it shouldn’t sag easily but maintains support.
Before going out to shop, make sure you have a set budget. Know that certain types of mattresses may come at a higher cost, like hybrids and latex mattresses. The price may also depend on the size of mattress you choose. Twin and full sizes will cost less than a queen or king size.
Online mattresses are a great option for those on a budget. Online stores cut out the middleman, and can, therefore, offer high-quality beds for less. It’s also easier to compare several mattresses at once instead of visiting several stores and face pressure to buy from salesmen.
Sleep Trials, Warranties, and Return Policies
Features like sleep trials, warranties, and return policies are ways to assure the customer of a good purchase. A mattress is a big investment— if a customer isn’t happy or satisfied with a new bed, especially one bought online, they don’t have to be stuck with it. Through a sleep trial and a return policy, customers can arrange the company to come pick up their mattress. If a customer loves their new mattress and decides to keep it, a warranty helps protect their investment.
A sleep trial is a great way to try out a new mattress within the comfort of your own home. Sleep trials offer plenty of time for the body to break in the mattress and adjust to it. If customers are not happy with the mattress within the sleep trial period, it can be picked up and donated for a full refund.
A warranty outlines what customers can expect from manufacturers, and what manufacturers can expect from customers. Always read the fine print to see what the policy is regarding defects and who will be covering additional fees like shipping and inspection fees, the customer or the manufacturer.
Read the policy to see what the guidelines and restrictions are, especially if shipping and handling costs are covered by the manufacturer or the customer. Return policies are sometimes offered in place of sleep trials—they last at least 30 days, the right amount of time it may take for the body to adjust to a new bed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if I’m a combination sleeper?
If you fall asleep on your side, but wake in the morning on your stomach, you’re a combination sleeper. Combination sleepers can switch between up to 2 to 3 different sleep positions.
Are pillows important? What about pillows?
Yes. Pillows cradle the neck and head, helping to keep the spine in alignment. You should have a pillow specifically for your sleep position. For example, someone who sleeps on their stomach needs a low-loft pillow— just enough loft to slightly lift and cradle the head and neck, but not enough to misalign the spine.
To write a quality and credible article, we considered over 31 leading mattress brands, read several dozen reviews and articles, and spent over __ hours researching, writing, and editing.
Have You Found the Best Mattress?
As a combination sleeper, the right mattress needs to offer the right support, especially when switching to different sleep positions all night A too soft or too firm mattress could throw the spine out of alignment due to excessive sagging or lack of cushioning. We highly recommend a medium-firm mattress that offers the perfect balance of comfort and support for each sleep position.