img

We may receive financial compensation for products purchased through links or codes on this website. SavvySleeper.org is owned by Healthy Sleep, LLC and includes Amerisleep, LLC advertising. Learn more

Best Innerspring Mattress: 2020 Buyer’s Guide

Malena Piper

·

If you crave the classic “bouncy” feeling of a mattress over firmer modern beds, you’re in luck. Innerspring mattresses, also known as spring beds, are still in high demand among sleepers.

Fans of innerspring beds know these traditional beds sleep a lot cooler than memory foam and other mattress styles. Innersprings typically have metal or steel coils in the base, and some are wrapped in fabric for better motion transfer (known as “pocketed coils”). Many brands have begun to “convert” their innerspring models to hybrids, which incorporate more foam into the top layers, adding more comfort and support.

In this article, we’ll look at different innerspring and hybrid mattresses with a variety of features and price ranges. Every innerspring mattress is designed differently, but they all aim to give you a good night’s sleep.

Best Innerspring Mattress

MattressHighlightsPrice
BEST INNERSPRING OVERALLAmerisleep AS3 Hybrid
The AS3 HybridAmerisleep
Bio-Pur® foam combined with pocketed coil base offers pressure relief and breathability.
$1189
BEST COOLING INNERSPRING MATTRESS Zoma Hybrid Mattress Triangulex® gel memory foam circulates air while pocketed coil base responds individually to movement.
$999
Brentwood Homes Oceano
Brentwood HomesOceano
Contains cooling gels to regulate your temperature.
$999
Ashley Chime Innerspring
AshleyChime
Innerspring
Affordable mattress great for guest rooms.
$400
E-Rest UltraFusion Hybrid
E-RestUltraFusion
Hybrid
Features a luxurious pillow top for added comfort.
$400
Tuft & Needle Hybrid
Tuft & NeedleHybrid
Contains T&N Adaptive® foam to relieve pressure points and prevent night sweats.
$1495

Best Innerspring Overall: AS3 Hybrid

as3 hybrid BEST INNERSPRING OVERALL
AS3 Hybrid

Amerisleep’s medium mattress is its most generalized hybrid model, suitable for back, side, and combination sleepers. It features three support zones for better sleep.

Receive 30% off the Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid

Enter AS30 at checkout

Get discount
Best mattress feature
  • HIVE® improves contouring and adds air channels for heat to escape.
  • Bio-Pur® adapts and snaps back into shape as you move for more comfortable sleep.
  • Bio-Pur® isn't 100 percent petrochemicals, unlike traditional memory foam.
Recommended for...
  • Combination sleepers looking for a responsive, medium feel mattress.
  • Side sleepers who want a conforming hybrid mattress that prevents back pain.
  • Back sleepers interested in the pocketed coils' targeted back support.

Amerisleep is known for their all-foam models, and recently they’ve introduced hybrids into their lineup as well. The AS3 Hybrid is a variation of their bestselling AS3, and with its medium feel and zoned coil support system, side and combo sleepers, plus couples, are sure to enjoy this comfortable bed.

First, the top layer of the AS3 is the plant-based Bio-Pur®. Instead of using foam made with 100% petrochemicals, Amerisleep replaces some of that petroleum with castor oil, creating a more breathable, responsive material—Bio-Pur®. When you lay down on this comfort layer, you won’t feel stuck or trapped, even as you change positions during the night. The open cell construction of the foam allows air to flow through it easily, preventing heat traps.

The targeted support offered by the coil layer gives every sleeper the pressure relief they need to sleep well. Since each coil is individually wrapped in fabric, each coil responds individually to movement on the surface. That way, there is limited motion transfer and no pressure build-up in the most sensitive areas, such as the back, neck, hips, and feet. The pocketed coils emit little, if any noise, so you can sleep soundly.

Along with a sturdy base foam, the AS3 Hybrid also has added edge support around the perimeter of the mattress. This stiff foam makes it easier to get in and out of bed.

The AS3 Hybrid ships free and comes with free returns, plus a 100-night sleep trial and a 20-year prorated warranty. During the first 10 years of the warranty, Amerisleep will repair or replace a mattress with manufacturing defects or sags greater than .75 inches. After the first 10 years, the customer will pay a portion of the repair and replacement costs.

Best Cooling Innerspring Mattress: Zoma Hybrid

zoma hybrid BEST COOLING INNERSPRING MATTRESS
Zoma Hybrid

The mattress mixes rejuvenating, responsive, and relaxing foams with a stable and buoyant pocketed coil system.

Receive $150 off the Zoma Hybrid

Enter WIN150 at checkout

Get discount
Best mattress features
  • Soft and breathable AirCloth cover releases absorbed heat quickly.
  • Triangular cutouts ease pressure in sensitive areas, while the midsection lacks cutouts for more support.
  • Durable and responsive pocketed coils and foam base maintain the mattress's structure.
Recommended for...
  • People of all activity levels looking for a relaxing and restorative mattress.
  • Hot sleepers interested in a durable and dynamic cooling mattress.

The Zoma Hybrid has four dynamic layers, each one addressing the common problems that sleepers face, such as pressure and heat build-up, spinal support, and contouring.

First, the Zoma Hybrid is fitted with a soft, contouring layer known as Triangulex™. This gel memory foam contains triangle-shaped cutouts to improve breathability and responsiveness. The triangles are grouped together at the head, shoulders, legs, and feet for excellent support. Even as you change positions, the triangles flex and contour to your body so you won’t feel stuck. The middle of the Triangulex™ layer contours closely to your back and hips for even more support.

Next comes the Reactiv™ layer, a bouncy, responsive transition foam that ensures the softer layer above it doesn’t sag or lose support. Thanks to Reactiv™, motion transfer is minimal, and you won’t experience the numbness or tingling that often comes from sinking down too far into a mattress.

The pocketed coil base layer responds to individual movements, further enhancing the support and contouring of the bed. Each coil moves with your body as you change positions. A durable base foam rounds everything out and ensures the upper layers don’t sag or develop soft spots over time.

The Zoma Hybrid comes with a 10-year warranty, plus free shipping, free returns, and a 100-night sleep trial.

Brentwood Home Oceano

brentwood home oceano BRENTWOOD HOME OCEANO
Brentwood Home Oceano

Two coil layers, a microcoil and base coil layer, improve the mattress’s contouring and support abilities.

Best mattress features
  • Microcoils paired with gel foam for a cool and contouring sleep surface.
  • Mattress cover of New Zealand wool wicks away heat and moisture.
  • Hundreds of pocketed coils arranged in five zones provide specialized support across the body.
Recommended for...
  • Sleepers who want the support and comfort offered by the coils' five zones.
  • Allergy sensitive sleepers who want a natural fiber mattress cover.

The Brentwood Home Oceano is a hybrid mattress boasting two different layers of innerspring technology. This, combined with multiple layers of memory foam, creates a unique support system. The innerspring bounce and the comfort level of a foam bed are combined perfectly.

The cover of the Oceano is made from a New Zealand wool. Because it’s a natural fiber, the wool cover helps wick away moisture and transfer body heat away from the sleeper better than synthetic material. The first layer of innersprings is a 4-inch top layer of 1,353 individually wrapped coils. These micro-coils are smaller than the actual innerspring layer beneath it. They are paired with a layer of gel memory foam to create pressure relief.

The larger, stronger innerspring layer is below, comprised of 796 individually wrapped base coils. These base coils are gathered in five particular “zones” to provide specific support to different areas of your body. Every Oceano is CertiPUR-US® certified, meaning the mattress is free of unhealthy chemicals. Be advised, the queen-size Oceano weighs 113 pounds, which is considerably more than other beds on the market.

Every Oceano mattress comes with a 25-year warranty and a one-year sleep trial. Both the warranty and the sleep trial last much longer than what’s offered for most mattresses on the market today. Oceano also offers free shipping.

Ashley Chime Innerspring-in-a-Box

Ashley Chime Innerspring-in-a-Box ASHLEY CHIME INNERSPRING-IN-A-BOX
Ashley Chime Innerspring-in-a-Box

An inexpensive mattress with Bonnell coil support that’s delivered straight to your home.

Best mattress features
  • Quilted cover and polyester finish discourage motion transfer from Bonnell coils
  • Bonnell coils maximize airflow to pull away heat and moisture.
  • Mattress is 8 inches thick and firm, capable of enduring a significant amount of expected wear and tear.
Recommended for...
  • Budget shoppers seeking an inexpensive innerspring that arrives at their front door.
  • Back sleepers or stomach sleepers interested in a firm mattress for supportive sleep.

Ashley Furniture has found a way to capture the popularity of the bed-in-a-box craze. They did this by using the traditional construction of an innerspring. Ashley’s Chime Innerspring-in-a-Box is an 8-inch mattress with a high firmness level. If you want a simple, strong mattress for a guest room or lower back support, you should consider this mattress.

The Chime mattress features a coil unit made from 13-gauge steel called Bonnell coils. Bonnell coil units differ from typical pocketed coils because they’re wrapped together. However, this can cause issues with motion transfer. To help, Ashley added a 2-inch quilted cover and a polyester finish to help promote motion isolation.

The Chime does not feature a sleep trial, so you won’t have a grace period to test the mattress. However, Ashley Furniture does offer a 5-year limited warranty on the Chime. If you’re immediately unsatisfied, the warranty is prorated and you can receive most of your money back.

E-Rest UltraFusion Hybrid

E-Rest UltraFusion Hybrid E-REST ULTRAFUSION HYBRID
E-Rest UltraFusion Hybrid

A 10-inch innerspring mattress with a “luxe pillow top” for a mix of softness and support.

Best mattress features
  • Rayon cover encourages a cool sleeping surface, while gel foam distributes absorbed heat evenly.
  • Pillow top provides a plush cushion for pressure relief and relaxation.
  • A durable mattress backed by a 20-year warranty.
Recommended for...
  • Bargain hunters shopping for a soft innerspring mattress.
  • Side sleepers interested in a bouncy, plush bed.

E-Rest’s UltraFusion Hybrid is a 10-inch hybrid mattress featuring the best of both innerspring and memory foam mattresses. It’s an affordable and versatile choice for multiple sleep styles.

The UltraFusion Hybrid starts with a “luxe pillow top” cover to provide maximum softness. The cover is made with rayon, which E-Rest claims is designed to promote coolness. Underneath is a hybrid of innerspring and memory foam.

The pocketed coils provide traditional support and structure. This helps with any back pain issues you might have. Protecting the coils is an additional fiber support pad, followed by a layer of gel foam. While the UltraFusion is available in any size, from twin to California King, every mattress is 10 inches thick.

UltraFusion mattresses are backed with a 20-year warranty from the manufacturer. These mattresses are available at specific retailers such as Bed Bath & Beyond. Warranty information is provided by the retailer, so contact them to learn more. There is no sleep trial window for an UltraFusion Hybrid.

Tuft & Needle Hybrid

tuft & needle hybrid TUFT & NEEDLE HYBRID
Tuft & Needle Hybrid

Five foam layers and an innerspring support encourages a good night’s rest.

Best mattress features
  • T&N Adaptive® balances conforming cushion with responsiveness.
  • A durable polyester cover protects the mattress.
  • Cool graphite gels disperses heat, while air travels between coils to pull heat away.
Recommended for...
  • People interested in an adaptable hybrid mattress.
  • Back sleepers hunting for a supportive mattress.

Tuft & Needle is known for affordable foam mattresses featuring a variety of support systems. They also offer a hybrid edition with innerspring layers.

Tuft & Needle mattresses feature a special proprietary layer of foam. This foam is designed specifically for pressure relief, which is ideal for sleepers who need pain relief or just want a softer top layer.

Each Tuft & Needle Hybrid features a polyester cover designed for durability. The focus for the cover is on comfort and durability, while the cooling gel in the foam layer below dissipates heat.

Tuft & Needle’s proprietary foam layer is called T&N Adaptive®. It’s designed to avoid the overly soft and sinking feeling of some foam mattresses. Underneath the T&N Adaptive® foam is traditional, pocketed innerspring coils. This layer gives the mattress its base structure and is responsible for providing firmness.

Back sleepers looking for back support and the comfort of foam will enjoy Tuft & Needle. The mattress also contains graphite cooling gels, which absorb and remove body heat.

Tuft & Needle offers a 10-year warranty on every mattress. This covers the manufacturing and material defects of every aspect of the mattress. It includes each foam layer and the mattress cover. Mattress sagging greater than 3/4 inches is covered, as is any splitting or cracking of the materials. The company also promotes a standard 100-night sleep trial with a free return at any time.

Mattress Types to Consider

You can’t be sure if an innerspring mattress will provide you the best night’s sleep possible unless you explore the other options on the market. Innerspring mattresses are available in a variety of models and can be combined with other styles to create hybrids. Let’s take a look at the most popular mattress types available today.

Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses feature at least one layer of metal coils. These mattresses usually include steel coils, which are created to provide support for sleepers. Innerspring mattresses have been around for a long time. Over the years, the method for creating spring beds has changed dramatically.

Today, innerspring beds are usually created with isolated, pocketed coils instead of a connected series of springs. The best construction for motion isolation and airflow is individually wrapped pocketed coils, but it’s not the only one. Innersprings can also be built with off-set coils or continuous, connected coils.

The most common coil types in innerspring mattresses are:

  • Bonnell coils: hourglass-shaped springs that flex easily when pressure is put on them. They are cheap to make but don’t last very long.
  • Continuous coils: a row of coils formed from a single wire piece. They are hinged together like offset coils.
  • Offset coils: even though they have an hourglass shape like Bonnell coils, they respond to motion slightly better than Bonnell coils.

If you’re shopping for quality, make sure you know the coil count. A good rule of thumb is more coils provide more comfort and support. The variety of firmness or softness in an innerspring bed comes from the coils’ strength.

The strength of the coil is referred to as the gauge. You should be able to locate a number that measures the gauge of the coils. The larger the number, the thinner the coil. The thinner the coil, the softer it is. If you’re looking for a bouncier, softer night’s sleep, aim for a higher gauge. If you suffer from back pain, a lower number will provide stronger, firmer support for you.

When you sleep on an innerspring, the coils are the last layer and furthest from the body. In other words, innerspring coils are on the bottom layer. Between the coils and your body is a comfort layer. The material for this comfort layer can vary. However, many popular hybrid mattresses use memory foam. In this layer, memory foam creates extra contouring and pressure point relief. The top layer is the cover. Just like the comfort layer, the varieties of materials and features for innerspring covers vary.

Motion transfer may be another concern. Unlike memory foam and latex, coils don’t isolate your movement. Their associated bounce increases motion transfer. This is why pocketed, individual coils are popular. If you can feel the coils in an innerspring mattress while sleeping, it’s a sign the comfort layer has worn down and it’s time to replace the bed.

Memory Foam Mattresses

Viscoelastic memory foam has become one of the most popular mattress materials. Bed in a box mattresses from online retailers promote the convenience of shipping compressed materials. But there are also sleep benefits to memory foam mattresses.

Memory foam contours around your body’s physical impression while your own heat helps to conform and soften the surface. This allows a gentle cradling of particular pressure point areas like the shoulders and hips. Memory foam beds boast some of the softest surfaces available and are gentle no matter your sleeping position.

Unlike innerspring mattresses, the distribution of pressure in memory foam is more contained. This means motion transfer is reduced when a sleeper changes position. So while memory foam beds don’t dissipate heat as easily, they cause far less of a disturbance when a sleeper moves. Some memory foam is known for emitting an off-gassing odor when it’s opened, but it should dissipate after a few days. Look for plant-based foams that emit little to no odor if this is a concern.

Most memory foam mattresses are built in layers. There’s usually a comfort layer on top to cradle and contour the body. These layers are usually made or injected with specific ingredients to boost cooling. Underneath is the support foam. Unlike comfort layers, these foam layers are responsive but increasingly firm. Most memory foam beds have a base foam layer with little response, designed to give the mattress its overall shape.

Memory foam beds have some problems traditional innerspring mattresses don’t. The most common issues are edge support and overheating. Cooling gels, graphite, and cutaway pockets in the foam layers are all common features. All of these reduce the risk of hot sleeping. Edge support can also be tricky. There are no metal coils to promote the shape of the bed, which means some memory foam beds can lose strength and shape around the edge over time. Fortunately, there are a variety of price points for any shopper.

Latex Mattresses

Latex mattresses are less similar to innerspring mattresses and closer to memory foam beds. The difference is the materials used in latex mattresses. You might be environmentally conscious or worried about synthetic ingredients in your mattress. If so, latex is a good choice.

Latex mattresses use natural latex foam derived from rubber tree sap. Some latex mattresses don’t use natural latex and blend synthetic imitations. However, natural latex beds trace their ingredients back to the environment. The rubber tree sap undergoes one of two processes— either Dunlop or Talalay. Both processes create a light and airy foam with better circulation than traditional memory foam.

Those with latex allergies may be less inclined to use this mattress. If you’re concerned, check with a doctor to be tested before trying a latex mattress in your home. Latex mattresses limit motion transfer better than innerspring mattresses, but not as well as most memory foams. And just like memory foam, latex mattresses have issues with edge support. Latex mattresses can also sometimes weigh more than memory foam or innerspring mattresses.

Hybrid Mattresses

If you like the softness, contouring, and comfort of memory foam but want the support and structure of an innerspring, try a hybrid mattress. A hybrid mattress is any mattress combining the dominant features of any memory foam, latex, or innerspring bed. Hybrids have become popular as they combine the strengths of memory foam and innerspring mattresses. They do this while canceling out the drawbacks of innerspring mattresses, such as edge support or motion transfer.

But hybrids aren’t perfect. To start, there’s a good chance you’ll spend more on a hybrid. Because the construction of these mattresses features both coils and foam layers, they are hefty both in price and weight. Most hybrid mattresses will be thicker and weigh more. When looking at a hybrid mattress, make sure it eliminates the individual problems of memory foam and innerspring mattresses. Overheating or too much bounce shouldn’t be an issue. A hybrid tries to eliminate the less desirable features of each mattress style.

Which Sleeping Position is Best for Innerspring Mattresses?

You should only purchase an innerspring mattress after you know your sleep style. Your sleep style is the position you most commonly sleep in. Most people are back sleepers, stomach sleepers, side sleepers, or combination sleepers. How you sleep will greatly impact which innerspring mattress is right for you.

Side Sleepers

Side sleeping is common, healthy, and catered to by most mattress manufacturers. The best mattress for side sleepers offers good blend of support and softness. They might gravitate more towards a memory foam or innerspring mattress depending on their priorities.

Side sleepers will appreciate the solid support of an innerspring mattress to help relieve lower back pain. As long as there’s adequate “give” in the coils, a side sleeper’s hips and shoulders should rest easily.

Side sleepers usually have issues with innerspring mattresses if there isn’t enough comfort on top. The pressure created by coils in innerspring mattresses can sometimes cause discomfort. This usually happens in the shoulders, neck, and back.

If you’re a committed side sleeper but want an innerspring mattress, it’s important to seek one with a plush, soft top layer. This helps avoid sharp pain in your pressure point areas. If there’s a great innerspring mattress lacking comfort, look to purchase a plush mattress topper to create an extra layer of comfort.

Back Sleepers

Innerspring mattresses are popular with back sleepers because of the support coils provide the lower back. Many people suffer from chronic lower back pain, and spring mattresses give great support.

If you’ve ever found yourself sleeping in a position specifically to alleviate back pain, try an innerspring. A very firm innerspring coupled with a pillow under the knees can make a world of difference for sleepers with lower back pain. Back sleepers often struggle with sleep apnea and snoring, so correct positioning of the head and neck is crucial.

Stomach Sleepers

Stomach sleeping is the least healthy position for long-term sleep. It might stop snoring, but it puts severe stress on the spine and neck. If you’re a stomach sleeper shopping for an innerspring mattress, make sure the surface is comfortable. Since most of your body will be against the cover and top layer, you’ll need to check its firmness and support. Some stomach sleepers desire the contoured sinking feeling from memory foam while some want the extra firmness of innersprings.

Sleeping Cool and Airflow

If you’re a committed side sleeper but want an innerspring mattress, it’s important to seek one with a plush, soft top layer. Doing so allows you to avoid sharp pain in your pressure point areas.

Cooling technology isn’t just popular in memory foam mattresses—  even innerspring or hybrid mattresses have cooling properties. Look for coils and cooling elements in the comfort layers. Innerspring mattresses also allow for airflow through the mattress, while memory foam does not. This is true even if your innerspring or hybrid has a memory foam layer at the top. Heat leaving a sleeper’s body can pass through the coils much more easily.

If you find you’re a hot sleeper even on a traditional innerspring mattress, you can still take steps to create a cooler sleeping environment. Try using cooling sheets on your mattress and making sure the airflow in the room is circulating properly. Cooling sheets are made from organic, breathable materials such as Tencel, organic cotton, or bamboo. Pillows made of breathable, natural materials like latex will also trap less heat as you sleep.

Mattress Budget

Innerspring mattresses can be purchased at almost any price point. First, start researching your needs and testing out the firmness and support of a variety of coils and gauges. More coils will always be more expensive, but more coils also bring more firmness, comfort, and quality.

Ask yourself a few questions. Is this mattress for everyday use, or is it going in a guest room? If it’s for you, what is your sleeping preference or potential health concern? If it’s for a guest bedroom, what basic features should it have to address the needs of most sleepers? What are the best firmness options? How long do you plan on keeping this mattress? If you want to make one purchase lasting for up to or over a decade, be prepared to spend more. Also, environmentally friendly mattresses or hybrid mattresses with multiple features are typically more expensive.

FAQs

Do you need a box spring for an innerspring mattress?

The real question here is whether or not your warranty requires you to place your mattress on a box spring to qualify for a potential replacement. Some mattress warranties won’t issue replacements, refunds, or even repairs if your mattress simply sits on the ground.

The best surface for a mattress is a hard, flat one. This can be part of an existing bed frame or a box spring. Many people use adjustable bases or special platforms instead of the traditional box spring. This often comes to a design choice for the bedroom. But as long as the innerspring mattress has a flat level of support underneath it, you can sleep easy.

Which is better: memory foam or an innerspring?

“Better” is all about preference. You can find luxury and affordable mattresses in either style, or you can also buy a hybrid boasting the best of both styles. There’s no definitive answer when it comes to quality, either. Each style of mattress can be constructed with longevity in mind. The number of springs in an innerspring mattress will determine both its support level and its quality over time.

Are innerspring mattresses for me?

Innerspring mattresses might not be as popular as most memory foam and mattress-in-a-box promotions. However, they certainly have an audience. Buying a high-quality innerspring mattress can give you a great night’s sleep. Just make sure there’s an appropriate comfort layer designed to work with a high number of coils. And always check the number of coils and the gauge you’re looking for.

What is the best innerspring mattresses for side sleepers?

Side sleepers need to look for a comfort layer or plush cover designed to give extra support to pressure points. It’s also possible side sleepers can take an existing innerspring mattress and modify the top. Aftermarket mattress pads and poly-foam covers can create extra cushioning if you need it.

How long do innerspring mattresses last?

Depending on the quality of the construction, innerspring mattresses can last a short amount of time or close to a decade. It’s all about coil count and coil gauge. The more coils and the stronger the gauge, the longer an innerspring mattress will be around.

Conclusion

There are a variety of mattress styles and even types of innerspring mattresses on the market. But there’s no single answer about which is the best mattress for you. You need to determine a budget, understand the needs specific to your sleep style (and any potential health concerns), and start shopping around. Sleep trials are definitely a helpful way for you to try a mattress with less financial risk.

Be sure to try a variety of innerspring mattresses. You might find a completely different experience between similar mattresses. One mattress featuring pocket coils might allow you to sleep differently than one with connected coils. Try a bed with a different coil system than your current one. A good idea is to rank your concerns as a sleeper— heat, motion transfer, back, pain, etc.— and shop for features that address those areas first.

Don’t be afraid to return a coil mattress if it doesn’t give you a great night’s sleep in the first few weeks. Mattress brands offer trials because they’re confident about their product. They believe their beds have quality materials and provide a comfortable sleeping experience. There’s nothing wrong with trying out a few different types of innerspring mattresses until you find one to give you a great night’s sleep.

Was this article helpful?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *